BusinessPostCorner.com
No Result
View All Result
Tuesday, July 15, 2025
  • Home
  • Business
  • Finance
  • Accounting
  • Tax
  • Management
  • Marketing
  • Crypto News
  • Human Resources
BusinessPostCorner.com
  • Home
  • Business
  • Finance
  • Accounting
  • Tax
  • Management
  • Marketing
  • Crypto News
  • Human Resources
No Result
View All Result
BusinessPostCorner.com
No Result
View All Result

What’s With All These No-Confidence Votes In University Presidents?

September 23, 2023
in Management
Reading Time: 3 mins read
A A
0
What’s With All These No-Confidence Votes In University Presidents?
ShareShareShareShareShare

Rutgers Univeristy’s faculty senate voted no confidence its its president, Jonathan Holloway, this … [+] week. It’s just the latest example of what appears to be a surge in such votes.

getty

The Rutgers University senate voted no confidence in president Jonathan Holloway on Friday. The vote was 89-47 and came after several unpopular actions Holloway had taken in recent months, including not renewing the contract of Nancy Cantor, the popular chancellor of the Newark campus, and threatening to file an injunction against Rutgers faculty during their strike last spring.

The Rutgers vote was the third such no-confidence vote against a university president in just the past month.

  • On September 19, the faculty of Webster University voted 59-41 to express no confidence in Chancellor Beth Stroble and President Julian Schuster over concerns about their financial management of the institution.
  • And in a case that’s drawn prolonged national attention, the West Virginia University Assembly voted it had no confidence in the leadership of President E. Gordon Gee. That vote, which passed by an overwhelming 797-100 margin, followed Gee’s proposal for massive cuts to WVU academic programs and faculty positions.

And that’s not all. Earlier this year, no-confidence votes in university leaders were also passed at several other institutions, including Bellarmine Univeristy, West Texas A&M University, Jackson State University, and the University of Arizona. According to a Chronicle of Higher Education analysis, at least 24 institutions took no-confidence votes in 2021, continuing an upward trend across the past decade.

Although votes of no confidence by the faculty carry no legal or official authority, they’re not without their consequences. Intended to upbraid a president, criticize a governing board, or call for the firing of other administrators, they often are an effective way of publicly dramatizing a faculty’s dissatisfaction with an institution’s leadership. While they might not be a knock-out punch, they still can bruise leaders, leaving them in a weakened state.

So what gives now? Why this spate of no-confidence votes? In our forthcoming book Colleges On the Brink, Chuck Ambrose and I discovered that while the reasons for no-confidence votes vary from institution to institution, the most common scenario in recent years has been faculty displeasure with large-scale academic restructuring and budget reductions directed by presidents and chancellors. Often those complaints center around what the faculty perceive to be administrators’ insufficient regard for shared governance in decision-making and financial affairs. They typically occur at institutions that are in very difficult financial straits.

How effective are no-confidence votes? Many observers dismiss them as merely symbolic, an acute symptom of chronic faculty unrest. But the Chronicle report cited above suggests they have more power than simply a show of angry hands. Of the 235 no-confidence votes between 1989 to 2022, just over half – 51% – of the leaders who’d been the target of the vote had left office within a year. A separate study of 57 no-confidence votes found that in 32 of those cases, the campus leader was out of office within six months.

While some institutions have formal guidelines for conducting no-confidence votes, others do not. They define the process for drafting a resolution, determining who gets to vote on it, and deciding how the vote will be taken as they move forward.

Even though no-confidence votes are non-binding, some faculty are reluctant to use them, nonetheless. Some may fear retribution from administrators, the governing board, or even other faculty. Others may worry that such a vote reflects poorly on an institution and will cause students, policy makers and the general public to doubt its stability and lose their own confidence in it.

However, as more institutions face serious budget deficits, and administrators feel forced to take dramatic steps to right the ship, expect more no-confidence votes to be forthcoming. History suggests they are often an effective means for faculty to challenge the process and results of major institutional changes.

Credit: Source link

ShareTweetSendPinShare
Previous Post

Rishi Sunak scraps home energy efficiency taskforce

Next Post

Bets on energy transition spark rise in North American pipeline deals

Next Post
Bets on energy transition spark rise in North American pipeline deals

Bets on energy transition spark rise in North American pipeline deals

Reddit introduces age verification in the UK ahead of new rules

Reddit introduces age verification in the UK ahead of new rules

July 15, 2025
After almost 250 years as a symbol, the Bald Eagle is finally the official bird of the United States

After almost 250 years as a symbol, the Bald Eagle is finally the official bird of the United States

July 13, 2025
Gemma Collins’ weight-loss drug Instagram post banned

Gemma Collins’ weight-loss drug Instagram post banned

July 8, 2025
Post Office could be owned by its workers, government says

Post Office could be owned by its workers, government says

July 14, 2025
Binance’s Grip Tightens: 2025 Mid-Year Data Shows Exchange Titan Pulling Ahead: CryptoQuant

Binance’s Grip Tightens: 2025 Mid-Year Data Shows Exchange Titan Pulling Ahead: CryptoQuant

July 10, 2025
UK housebuilders agree to pay £100m to avoid legal decision

UK housebuilders agree to pay £100m to avoid legal decision

July 9, 2025
BusinessPostCorner.com

BusinessPostCorner.com is an online news portal that aims to share the latest news about following topics: Accounting, Tax, Business, Finance, Crypto, Management, Human resources and Marketing. Feel free to get in touch with us!

Recent News

Home buyers have more negotiation power than they’ve had in years

Home buyers have more negotiation power than they’ve had in years

July 15, 2025
FTSE 100 hits 9,000 points for first time

FTSE 100 hits 9,000 points for first time

July 15, 2025

Our Newsletter!

Loading
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • DMCA

© 2023 businesspostcorner.com - All Rights Reserved!

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Business
  • Finance
  • Accounting
  • Tax
  • Management
  • Marketing
  • Crypto News
  • Human Resources

© 2023 businesspostcorner.com - All Rights Reserved!