Unlock the Editor’s Digest for free
Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favourite stories in this weekly newsletter.
Here is the Spanish puzzle. On paper, they are not a defensive team. They aim to spend games with every outfield player in the other team’s half — a high-wire act, because the slightest slip would leave an opponent in acres of space bearing down on Spain’s goal. Their goalkeeper, Unai Simón of modest Athletic Bilbao, probably isn’t even the best Spanish keeper.
Yet La Roja (“The Reds”) to date have the best defence in the World Cup. Heading into Friday’s quarter-final against Belgium, Spain have not conceded a goal in five games here. In fact, Simón has gone 609 minutes at the World Cup since 2022 without conceding, an all-time tournament record. Defence is why Spain are undefeated in 35 matches. Spain’s theory of defending rests on a basic insight. In the dictum of Johan Cruyff, the inventor of modern football and especially today’s Spanish version: “There is only one ball. If we have it, they can’t score.”
The story starts with Cruyff. The Dutchman played for Barcelona in the 1970s, and when he returned in 1988 as manager, he made every side from the under-10s to the first team play the same style. They defended on the halfway line and pressed the instant they lost the ball. He introduced a training exercise that remains the staple of almost every Barcelona practice today: the rondo, essentially, a piggy-in-the-middle game in which players interpass in a confined space, while opponents try to intercept. “Barcelona don’t train! They just play little games,” other clubs used to mock. Many of them have since adopted it. The rondo captures the essence of Cruyffian football: time, space, passing and geometry.
Cruyff found a 17-year-old in Barça’s academy, the Masia, who could not tackle and, the Dutchman told him, ran “like my grandmother”. But the youngster, Josep “Pep” Guardiola, could read the game. He became Cruyff’s best disciple. “I knew nothing about football until I met Cruyff,” Guardiola later said. He became the most influential coach of this century, updating and spreading Cruyffian football. Spain’s defence today is Cruyffian. That helps explain why Barcelona, the most Cruyffian club, produced about half the national team’s current starters, while the tactically sophisticated Basques supplied the coach Luis de la Fuente and several more players. There is only one Real Madrid player in the squad.
In Spanish thinking, possession is nine-tenths of the game. Guardiola’s Barcelona aimed to have the ball for about two-thirds of each match. Spain’s average at this World Cup is precisely 66 per cent, the most of any team at the tournament. The saying inside Barça is that there are two kinds of teams: those that organise themselves around the ball and those that disorganise themselves chasing it. Because Spain prioritises passing, almost every Spanish player looks like a midfielder. The country produces so few specialist defenders that it had to naturalise Aymeric Laporte, a Frenchman who moved to Spain aged 16, and put him in the national team.
Spain do not even aspire to rapid attacks. Instead, they advance as a bloc, exchanging passes, keeping their lines close together, with ideally only about 35 metres between the last defender and the most advanced forward. Rodri in central midfield, the “pivote” in Spanish football language, is responsible for ensuring that distances remain short. Forgoing quick counter-attacks can make scoring difficult. Other than their 4-0 romp over weak Saudi Arabia, Spain have just five goals in four games. The current side recalls the Spanish “tiki-taka” world champions of 2010, who scored a mere eight goals in seven games but conceded only two.
Then, as now, when Spain lose the ball, all their players are close together, leaving no gaps. That makes their press so effective. On average, Spain win the ball back 11.57 seconds after losing it — the quickest for any team left in the tournament. Since they seldom have defenders in their own half, any opponent venturing there is likely to be offside. Their offside trap has ensnared opponents 18 times, again the most for any team.
Goalkeeper Simón alone is responsible for his entire half, often coming far out to act as sweeper. That means he is selected more as a footballer and defensive organiser than as a shot-stopper. David Raya of Arsenal, the Premier League’s keeper of the year for three seasons running, sits on Spain’s bench. Simón only needs to stop a shot (including weak ones) about once a game. La Roja have conceded five shots on target in five games, while opponents have touched the ball just 41 times in the Spanish penalty area — the lowest for any team.
When Spain do take the lead, opponents rarely have a chance to equalise because there is only one ball and they do not have it. Spain play it around in an endless rondo, as if in a training session on the sunlit fields of Barcelona’s Masia. Opponents faced with the tactic can descend into impotent frustration. Uruguay, chasing a 1-0 deficit, ended up just kicking Spaniards.
There is another way to defend a lead. It is what England did against Mexico, and Egypt against Argentina: retreat into your own penalty area, and tackle, head and hoof every ball straight back to the opposition. When this works, as it did for England, it looks heroic. Spain’s defenders could not play this way even if they wanted to. For them, the best form of defence is possession.
Data analysis and visualisation by Dan Clark
Credit: Source link
